June 2004

CSPRA Book Reviews
by Robert Pavlik


A Land Between: Owens Valley, California
by Rebecca Fish Ewan

For many Californians, Inyo and Mono Counties are often referred to as "The East Side," as in east of the Sierran crest. It's a funny reference, if you think about it, because there's still a lot of California between Mount Whitney and the state boundary. Perhaps it's the high and dry nature of the region, or its lack of a major population center. It has long been a land of resources and recreational opportunities, and its remoteness has given rise to the creation of numerous myths and legends. A land apart.

Owens Valley, in particular, is a land between, as Rebecca Fish Ewan so gracefully illustrates. It lies between the towering Sierra Nevada to the west, and the White Mountains and the Inyo Range to the east, nearly as tall as their granitic counterparts across the valley. It is a land of change and stasis, displacement and the home of the displaced, alternately cataclysmic and quiet.

Its amazing how many people have a story about the East Side. Dave Alvin of the Blasters fame has written poems about his trips to Owens Valley. Generations of Angelenos have traveled up highways 14 and 395 to fish the rivers, streams and lakes, to hike into the backcountry in summer and ski at Mammoth Mountain over the long winter months.

The author has a few favorite Owens Valley stories, too, along with a retelling of some of the region's most famous historical events. The book is divided into three parts, "A Land Between," which focuses on the physical geography and natural history of the basin; "Dwelling Before," detailing the occupation of the Valley by the Numu (also known as Owens Valley Paiute) and early pioneers up until the watershed year 1913; and from 1913 until the present, the Valley as the scene of pitched battles fought over water, citizenship (specifically the internment of Japanese-Americans at Manzanar), and make-believe shootouts captured on celluloid by the Hollywood movie makers.

It's a story well told, interwoven with the author's personal history and some fictional accounts based on the lives of those who struggled to wrest a living out of the high desert. For the knowledgeable reader there's not a lot of new historical information here, but it does contain fresh insights and perspectives that a landscape architect brings to the subject. The book is dotted with black-and-white photographs, historic and contemporary, some of which are quite beautiful. There is a nice bibliographic essay at the end, which includes a filmography related to the Valley. And, the book is a nice size to carry along with you as you create your own memories of a land between.

 

Rebecca Fish Ewan, A Land Between: Owens Valley, California. Baltimore and London: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 2000, published in cooperation with the Center for American Places, Center Books on Space, Place, and Time. Xix + 221 pp.; photos, notes, bibliography, index; paper, $22.50.